Tuesday, November 18, 2008
City of Glass
The artwork of Mazzucchelli adds another dimension to the story, and is able to portray emotion and mood very effectively despite often being highly abstract. A good example of this, and also one of my favorite scenes, was the "speech" given by the young Peter Stillman. A tic-tac-toe game, an inkwell and an acoustic guitar are only a few of the things from which Peter's word balloons come from. I thought this worked very well considering the Peter's mysterious nature and use of words that did not make sense. In some way, it really added to his character by making him seem even more removed from reality. There are so many more panels that I could talk about, because each was unique. Another set I enjoyed were the ones spelling out "tower of babel" in Quinn's notebook. I also really liked the full page panel with the detailed realistic map of New York, featuring Quinn walking on top of it. I think Mazzucchelli really captured the essence of Auster's work in his depiction, in fact, I think he even managed to elevate it!
Quinn is the character that I felt I got to know the most about, and felt so much sympathy for. You can't help but feel his loneliness radiate off of the page. I also found the elder Peter Stillman fascinating, though not much is told about him beyond his visions and what he had done to his son. It left me wondering what his ultimate goal was before he killed himself. I enjoyed the character of Paul Auster as well, especially because it made the book seem even more like a metafiction. He played a more prominent role that I thought he would. But who is the overall narrarator? That is what really got me in the end!
I only just read City of Glass today, but I feel like I should read it again...and again.
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
Serenity
The cover features two of the characters: Mal, the captain of Serenity and the central figure in the series, and Inara, who's backstory and significance isn't explained within the story. Serenity looms eerily behind them, and they are bathed in blue, foggy light. There are also fireflies flying amongst them, which is significant because their ship, Serenity, is a "firefly" ship (named so because of its design). The comic (and movie) are named after their ship, which is named after The Battle of Serenity Valley, the final battle of the Unification War (in which most of the characters fought on the losing side). Mal looks off to the side with his hands clenched, and Inara stares forward. Both look serious. What struck me most about the design of this comic was its very life-like design. All the characters are drawn to look extremely similar to their television/movie counterparts. This must have been nice for fans of the series, as it probably made it easier to relate the comic to the greater whole. It is always interesting to see how the artwork is done when a life-action movie or tv series is developed into a comic book. I also enjoyed the character portraits done by different artists that were scattered throughout the book. Each showcased a unique style and take on the characters. This was different from any of the other comics that we have read so far, in genre, style and action. Serenity is pretty violent, and the action scenes were very well done. The dark coloring also gave on the feeling that they were in space with the characters, and set an intense mood to go with the fast paced action.
A scene that really struck me was the one where Mal, Zoe and Jayne are exploring the ship from the battle of Sturges. After the shootout with Dobson, a couple panel showcases floating droplets of blood. I think that whole exchange would have to be my favorite part of the story. This really struck me for some reason, as it reaffirmed to me that all this action was taking place in space. Each character in the series has left me wanting to learn more about them. Each seems to have a mysterious cast and a variety of motives for being a part of the crew. I was on the fence about Mal for awhile before finally deciding that he's a good guy, as he tends to come off as a jerk. The dynamics of the crew is also interesting. I can't say which one I like the most, as they are all equally fascinating at this point. Each seems to fill a particular niche within the crew, and though there is obvious tension between all of them (except for between zoe and wash), I cannot imagine them being able to subsist without each other. I think the idea of getting to know these characters more is what has got me wanting more!
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
It's A Bird (It's a Plane), it's a graphic novel you must read!
The cover shows Steve walking though the streets of a strange looking city. Everyone around him bears the Superman logo. He holds a notebad and pen and is writing. The surrounding figures are drawn in a different style and are a bit less colored. Their faces are emotionless. The cover seems to express how the protagonist feels; alienated from soceity. A piece of ripped notebook paper lies in the top left corner, three lines are crossed out and only one remains - It's a Bird. The title is derived from one of the many classic sayings used in conjunction with Superman: "It's a bird, it's a plane, no, it's Superman!!!!"
Teddy Kristiansen's artwork parallels the complex and interesting storyline. He won an Eisner for his work on It's A Bird, and it's no wonder! I noticed that throughout the story there was an extensive use of red. I thought this was interesting to compare to the story about the colors of Superman's uniform, one of which is red. Most of the other colors were subdued, but red is a prevailing color. His style is also very unique, as most of it is painted. The style of the art also changed with the different stories, and varied from extremely abstract (like in "The Costume") to very detailed (like in "Leaving Krypton"). He also creates very interesting panels.
It's hard for me to pick a favorite section, as I loved all the superman stories. My favorites would have to be his analyzation of the letter S, his analyzation of color, and "The Outsider." The first two reminded me of things we learned how to do in Scott McCloud's books (ha!), and the other really showcased the contradictions between Superman and the normal citizens he tries to live among. His perfection and invulnerability leave people completely unable to relate to him. There were so many meanings to each story because of the ways in which they paralleled Steve's real life story.
I'm curious as to what stories Steve came up with in the end...
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood
I adore the style of Persepolis. Satrapi did the whole novel in black and white, and uses negative space to create characters and shapes much of the time. Her use of black and white and relatively simple shapes and characters really add to the overall feel of the story. I found that her art reminded me of the murals found at many ancient persian sites, and the way she styles some of her panels (especially those in which she has many of the same soldier or corpse over and over) seemed to parallel ancient artwork. Another thing to note is the cover of the volume. It is very colorful except for the character represent herself, who sits vieled and staring, drawn in black and white. Both the entire cover and the drawing of her are surrounded by an ornate frame. The text is cracked and wavy, reminding one of the walls of ruins or pillars.
The relationship between Marjane and her grandmother was especially interesting. Her grandmother seems to have been extremely important to her whole family, and provided a sort of moral backbone and support. The few details about her grandmother's life were fascinating, and I would like to learn more. Marjane Satrapi wrote another graphic novel, entitled Embroideries, in which her grandmother is the main character. Besiders Marjane herself, I found her uncle Anoosh to be very interesting. He seems to have had a profound impact on her life, even after his execution. Their story was one of my favorites to read, as well as the one describing the homecoming of the released political prisoners. Both were fascinating, and at times humorous despite the circumstances the characters were living in.
I'll have to buy the next volume, and I think I'll rent the movie again!
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Death Note: The Last Name
I went with a classmate of mine to see Death Note, and was glad to have the company. Unfortunately I arrived a few minutes late and missed out on seeing some kids who came in costume! We were both hoping that the movie would be subtitled, as neither of us are big fans of dubbing. I think that the translation done for dubbing is often not as close to the original as the subtitle, and usually the voices just seem WAY too awkward and cheesy when matched with the actor. Unfortunately the showed the dubbed version but it was easy to get past the english voices/japanese actors after awhile. Death Note is very psychologically and morally complex, and I think the movie did a good job of portraying it. For most of the time that I was watching, I was very anxious! Since they changed so much from the manga, even I did not know what was going to happen, haha. There was one important event that was very different from the manga - Light actually succeeds in killing L! In the manga he tricks Rem into killing both Watari and L. Another guy then becomes L's replacement. It makes sense that they would change this in the movie, as it is a bit much to have an entirely new L halfway through the film. The rest of the events proceeded as they did in the manga (though with the different L). Though the movie ended in a lighter tone than the manga, the death of Light was dark as it was in the manga, and the actor who played Light did an excellent job of portraying him during his death scene. I read in an interview that the two actors who played Light and L got so into their characters that they barely even spoke with each other when the camera wasn't rolling! I'd like to see the L spin-off next, because his character is fascinating. I'm a lover of sweet but seeing him constantly eating candy dipped in sugar and syrup made me a bit queasy...
I think the film definitely had a message about justice and the law that was similar to that of the manga, despite the changes. I would definitely recommend seeing this film to anyone who is a fan of the manga or anime, or even enjoys a good j-movie!
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Astro City...Continued
I think what has me so hooked on this comic book is the character development. Action isn't much of the focus in these first few stories, but rather the people who are affected by it and the superheroes who are taking part.
While I very much enjoyed each of the stories, my favorites would have to be two that do not really focus on the superheroes themselves - "The Scoop" and "Safeguards." Like Busiek mentioned in his introduction, it is a completely different approach to explore the ways in which normal people who live in this "superhero world" are affected. That idea is not something that I had ever really thought of before, but it makes sense that people living amongst super human beings would have a different mentality than those who do not. This is apparent in the way Marta looks up in awe at Winged Victory and is fascinated by the humanity of Nick Furst. What I also enjoyed about this story was the juxtaposition of the seemingly "old world" type magic and creatures of Marta's Shadow Hill neighborhood vs. the "steel and glass," superheroes and villians of downtown Astro City. I'm still trying to figure out what exactly it was that changed for Marta and convinced her to stay in Shadow Hill. I found the story very complex and believable, because the outcome wasn't necessarily what I expected.
The ending of "Scoop" was what really made me smile. I think it was my favorite story of the whole volume because its amusing way of expressing the importance of truth, especially in reporting. The whole story I was so anxious to see what the article was going to end up being about! It was a interesting angle to approach the story from, and I found myself wishing I was sitting in that office listening to the story from Mister Mills himself. What a great character! Even in Astro City, where it's obvious that superheroes exist, it is still important that the news does not become sensationalized. Even in the presence of the supernatural, it is still important to get the cold hard facts before publishing a story. I think that this story spoke to more than just the Astro City enws...
Of the superheroes of Astro City, Samaritan interests me the most. I was glad to find out his back story when he explains it to Winged Victory, as it added a new element to his character. The conversation between Winged Victory and Samaritan (or rather, their alter egos) was my favorite part of that whole story, because it showed these two superheroes having a very real debate about the motives behind their actions. It showed that superheroes are still capable of having doubts, just like the other Astro City citizens.
Comic Book Confidential
And what a goldmine of interviews! Everyone from Stan Lee to Bill Griffith spoke, and I hung on their every word. Their interviews really spoke to the ways in which comic books reflect the social mentalities of their time. I always enjoy seeing the faces and hearing the voices behind a comic book, but to listen to them read their own work was beyond words! There is something fascinating about listening to a writer read their work in the way they imagine it. I like to then compare it to the way I imagined their characters sounding! R Crumb was my favorite to see interviewed.
All the original footage also added a lot to the documentary. It's fun to see all the underground comic book artists at work, as well as see footage of the hearings on the dangers of comic books. The arguments being made seem almost humorous (yet believable) now, but I can see how they would have been detrimental and suffocating to the industry.
I would definitely recommend this documentary to any one interested in learning more about the complex world of the comic book!
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
LittleBigPlanet
Kurt Busiek's Astro City
Every aspect of this comic is so beautiful. The cover, the panels, the writing. I found myself disappointed when the story was over because I just wanted more. I like how each chapter revolves around a different character existing in Astro City. Each individual is fascinating.
Busiek's introduction was also very interesting. I really appreciated what he had to say about the superhero genre and how it's not limited, but rather, limitless. I thought that was a great way to answer the criticism people have of superhero comics. Busiek proves his argument through this work.
Is it just me or does the cover remind you of magazine covers from the 40's and 50's? There is something so nostalgic and crisp about it.
Scott McCloud's Making Comics
I also really liked the exercises and notes he has at the end of each chapter. I have yet to do the exercises, but I am sure I will before I begin to create my own comic. I've never taken a class where I've had to create something completely of my own imagination, and I was really nervous when it came time to write the proposals. I've always liked to doodle and daydream, but to share my ideas with others was a terrifying thought! My main fears were, "can i make something interesting???", "what makes a good comic book story??" McCloud put these fears to rest when he explains that there is no right story for comics, and that one should write what they would want to read. His comment that even if all else fails there will be at least one loyal reader really made me smile.
On a side note, I'd really like to see the results that come of the 24 hour comic creation. Maybe we can get the class together for an all day (literally) event... ; )
Monday, October 6, 2008
Death Note -- The movie!
I have always found film adaptations of manga and comic books particularly interesting. Not only must a director and screenwriter deal with adapting the script, they must also deal with the vision of the artist, and what is being expressed in each panel. As we've been learning in class with our breakdowns, each panel can be thought of as a separate scene. Ryuk so much resembled the manga character, and I did not find myself thrown off by his animation at all. Considering that much of Death Note is narration and inner conversation, I thought the filmakers did an excellent job translating the turmoil to the big screen.
Death Note was hugely successful in Japan, and spawned a spin off film called L: Change the WorLd. I am curious to see this film as well, since it focuses on the life of L, and is not based off of any manga. It was just released this year in Japan, so hopefully we will be seeing it stateside sometime soon.
I am really looking forward to seeing the second part of the film next Thursday. Perhaps I will break out the eyeliner and white tee and dress as L. I imagine Death Note II: The Last Name is even darker considering what happens in the manga, but...my lips are sealed!
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Death Note
The first thing that attracted me to manga was the artwork. I was drawn to the big-eyed characters and fantasy creatures set against realistic backgrounds. The ways in which Japanese illustrators are able to use black and white (and gradients) to express so much really impressed me. I am an especially big fan of Takeshi Obata's work (including Hikaru no Go). Ryuk actually gave me nightmares!! As did many of Light's expressions of rage...
When I first started reading manga, the original publishers would flip the artwork so English readers could still read from right to left and front to back. This would often leave the original concepts for the artwork hard to understand. Luckily, with the huge surge of interest in manga, publishers do as much as they can to have the English versions resemble the original Japanese manga. I found this really well done in Death Note.
Controversy has undoubtedly followed Death Note, though it has not stopped its popularity. Both an anime series and live action film have been created and met with much success. A trailer for the live action film can be found, here. And if you are an anime fan, episodes of the popular TV show can be found, here.
Another tidbit I found interesting was that Tsugumi Ohba remains a mystery to the general public, much like the character L.
Rereading Death Note allowed me to see more clearly the differences and specialties of manga that Scott McCloud touches upon in his book.
Wednesday, September 17, 2008
Understanding Comics: Part II
One of the concepts I found most interesting was that of the balance between pictures and words, and the different moods and emotions that can be evoked by something as seemingly simple as a line.
Will Eisner: Portrait of a Sequential Artist
I also enjoyed all the other interviews with Jerry Robinson, Art Speigelman and Gerard Jones.
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
New Yorker Festival
Art Spiegelman
“Breakdowns: Comix 101”
Art Spiegelman won a Pulitzer Prize in 1992 for his graphic novel in two parts, “Maus: A Survivor’s Tale.” He is the author of “In the Shadow of No Towers” and the children’s book “Open Me . . . I’m a Dog!” With Françoise Mouly, he co-edited several volumes of the comics anthology “Little Lit.” He will publish two new books in October: “Jack and the Box,” a children’s book, and “Breakdowns: Portrait of the Artist as a Young %@&*!,” a memoir that includes a selection of his experimental comics from the nineteen-seventies.
4:30 p.m. Ailey Citigroup Theater, Joan Weill Center for Dance
405 West 55th Street
----------------------------------------------
- Worst Nightmares Part 2: “Fear(s) of the Dark”
- 10 p.m. IFC Center
323 Sixth Avenue - ---------------------------------------------------------------------
Following a special screening of the new animated film “Fear(s) of the Dark,” a compendium of animated shorts about phobias, Charles Burns and Lorenzo Mattotti, two of the film’s directors, will talk with Françoise Mouly.
Charles Burns is a cartoonist and illustrator, and a contributor to The New Yorker. His award-winning graphic novel “Black Hole” is being adapted for film by the director David Fincher. His other books include “El Borbah,” “Big Baby,” and “Skin Deep.”
Lorenzo Mattotti is a graphic artist. In 2003, he won an Eisner Award for his comic-book adaptation of “Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde.” His other comic albums include “Fires,” “The Man at the Window,” “Stigmates,” and “Caboto,” which was commissioned by the Spanish government for the quincentennial of Columbus’s voyage to America. He has contributed illustrations and cover art to The New Yorker.
Françoise Mouly is the art editor of The New Yorker and the founder and co-editor of RAW, which first published Charles Burns and Lorenzo Mattotti in the early eighties. She recently launched TOON Books, a new imprint of hardcover comics for beginning readers.
TICKETS ARE STILL AVAILABLE FOR BOTH EVENTS!!
Hope to see you there : )
Scott McCloud's "Understanding Comics"
What many view as a simple form of expression is actually far far from it. Branching from Will Eisner's original idea of comics as "sequential art," McCloud provides a definition of comics before further delving into every sensory and imaginative process that goes into a comic creation. I thought Understanding Comics would be easy to read through, as it is designed as a comic book itself (an easily accessible form)! However, I found myself enthralled by all the different theories McCloud presented, and it took me more than a few minutes to truly grasp what he is trying to convey. I read and studied each page thoroughly and was excited by the way McCloud is able to capture and explain the beauty and potential of comics. The way in which he breaks down and explains various techniques (such as different panel transitions) provided a number of insights into both reading and creating comics. I read The Spirit: Umbrella Handles after reading Understanding Comics and found myself analyzing the changes in action over panels, the dialogue, the use of icons. However, McCloud conveys his knowledge in a way that doesn't take the fun out of comics but rather enhances a reader's experience.
There are many terms McCloud defines in his book, the first and foremost being "comics" itself. The following are a list of important vocabulary and "comics language":
Comics (as defined by Scott McCloud): "Juxtaposed pictorial and other images in deliberate sequence, intended to convey information and/or to produce an aesthetic response in the viewer."
Splash page: a full page drawing, often including the title and credits as the first page of a comic book
Thought balloon: internal character dialogue, usually represented in a bubble
Narrative box: narrative boxes are used to convey information not easily understood through thought or speech bubbles and drawings
panel: bordered images, each usually representing a different subject, scene or action; often aligned in a grid format
closure: the mental process that allows readers to imaginatively fill in the spaces in between the panels
gutter: the spaces in between the panels which serve just as important a role as the panels themselves
Will Eisner's "The Spirit"
This week, we read THE SPIRIT: Umbrella Handles, by Will Eisner. Eisner is a true icon in the world of comics, otherwise known as sequential art (a term he created that Scott McCloud will later use in Understanding Comics). He created and produced The Spirit in the early 1940's as a weekly newspaper insert. The Spirit is a masked vigilante, who battles everyone from barons to femme fatales in order to bring justice to his city. The series is highly regarded for employing many style and storytelling conventions still popular today. Frank Miller wrote and directed a movie based on the series, to be released in December of this year. A trailer for the movie can be found here. I had never actually read any of The Spirit until this week, and all the posters and previews for the movie definitely piqued my interest. I enjoyed it very much and could see many techniques in Eisner's work that demonstrated his profound impact on the world of comics. I especially liked what he said about using his splash page as a sort of prologue to his story, rather than using it as another showy title page. He makes clear that story should be just as important to the comic as art, and one should not be downgraded for the other. This conviction is clear within his work. I loved the way it ended just like it began, with The Spirit unconscious in the snow. The story was also pretty hilarious at times, as was the way much of the action progressed. The timelessness of The Spirit was echoed on every page. I loved the simplicity of Sam and the evil-doings of the Baron. Each of his characters seemed to have a very distinct personality.
Can't wait to read more!